Showing posts with label Controversy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Controversy. Show all posts

Wednesday, 6 July 2016

A Mature Man's Guide to Feminism

The word "feminism" gets tossed around a lot these days, and I've wanted to write a sensible think-piece about what it means to be a good male feminist for some time. I juggled trying to be funny or light-hearted, but in my experience that devalues the seriousness of the subject matter and can also come across as condescending, so I'm going to try and avoid that.

Why do I want to write about feminism?

Because I think there are too many people who still have confused notions about what feminism really is, and in particular, far too many men who may be confused about what it represents and what it ultimately means for both sexes. I personally feel more comfortable addressing my own gender because I don't have the authority to discuss experiences I have not been privileged to (i.e. life from a women's perspective). What follows, therefore, is a guide for what I believe feminism truly is and why it's important for men to embrace it.

Why do I use the word "mature" in the title of this article? Because I believe there has to be a willing mindfulness on anyone's part to fully understand and appreciate any ideological concept, let alone follow through on it. If you don't approach this sort of thing with an open mind, you probably won't even get through the next paragraph without rage-quitting this article.

Where should we begin? Well...


. . . first, you have to understand what feminism actually is.

Feminism is the belief that women deserve to be treated as equally as men. That's it, and it doesn't get more complicated than that. Anyone that tries to convince you there's more to feminism than one, simple ideology is attaching more weight than is necessary. That is not to say that actually following through on this belief doesn't involve some degree of effort and mindfulness, but everything essentially boils down to this one idea. If someone asks whether you are a feminist, there's no need to meditate on it at length or attach any "but" statements to your qualification. If you believe that women are equal to men, then you are by definition a feminist. It's important to remember that it all boils down to one, simple qualification and...


. . . ignore anything that detracts from it.

There were times when I doubted whether or not I could call myself a feminist. I've had other self-proclaimed feminists tell me that I'm either not a real feminist or at least a horrible one, not because my mindset deviated from the ideological belief that women are equal to men, but because I didn't conform to the very rigid expectations they had attached to the movement.

It took me a long time to realize that feminism is not a club with only a small number of eligible members; the actual movement and advocacy involves a huge amount of people, and like any large movement, there will be an inevitable degree of selfishness from some individuals who warp or twist it to their own selfish agenda. I know a number of people who are nervous to identify as feminists because they don't want to be associated with some of the more militant or aggressive advocates (who they feel represent the movement as a whole). This is incredibly unfortunate, but we must remember that negative representation isn't a feminist tendency - it's a human tendency. Feminism itself is still the simple belief that women are equal to men, and once we unequivocally support that belief, we can ...


. . . understand what people mean by "privilege." 

"Privilege" gets thrown around like a dirty word these days; it is and always has been a word associated with negativity and shame. Two decades ago the word was used in reference to people with wealth and money - people who didn't understand what it was like to be middle/lower class. Nowadays, it crops up in terms like "white/male privilege," and it's important to understand what the word means in that context because although it still holds a degree of negativity, being called privileged isn't necessarily bad.

To admit that one is privileged is to make the mindful admission that one has certain benefits within a cultural/societal system wherein one demographic is afforded more advantages than another. I live in Canada, and I am a healthy/straight/white/Christian/male. Each of those self-descriptors inhabits a category of which my affiliation benefits the most, and in that way, I am an incredibly privileged person. I have never been discriminated against because of my sexual orientation, the colour of my skin, my religious preference, or my gender, but I acknowledge there are people that have. I understand that racism, sexism, and ableism exist in my culture and there are individuals who are/will be unfairly discriminated against.

We have to remember that human culture is based on tribalism - congregating among groups of like-minded and similar people for the purpose of survival - an instinct engrained via evolution since we were primates. We have evolved to be cautious around those that are different from us, and when one group greatly outnumbers another in a multicultural society, the predominant "tribe" is afforded preferential treatment simply because they fall in line with what the majority expects. The majority of the population in the west are white-skinned, and thus visible minorities are at a disadvantage, just as the predominant sexual orientation is straight and therefore anything that deviates from that is still met with caution. There are demographics and members of the population who must overcome more challenges than others because of circumstances they have no control over.

In regards to feminism, men need to acknowledge that in almost all areas of life, being male bears no negative consequence; a man will rarely be refused service, be less likely to qualify for a job, or be more likely to be sexually assaulted simply because they are a man. Women, however, live with a host of scenarios and circumstances in which the simple nature of being a woman will influence how they are treated. Broadly speaking, women will statistically make less money than their male co-workers, suffer gender-based harassment on a sometimes daily basis, and astronomically be more likely to be the victim of sexual assault. It is important for men to acknowledge this divide, because...


. . . the most important thing you can do is listen.

Privilege exists in any culture, and its problem is that it limits the experiences a group of people is able to appreciate. In regards to feminism, men will never experience what it is like to be a woman (regardless of how empathetic or sensitive we may feel we are) and thus we will also never encounter the varying degrees of sexism inherent to our culture. We will rarely ever have sexually inappropriate slurs thrown at us on the street by complete strangers; we will rarely have to worry that our qualities will be judged solely on our physical appearance; we will never feel like we are pressured to perform sex acts because we accepted to go on a date; we will never have our credibility questioned for reporting a heinous crime like rape; and we will never have decisions regarding what we choose to do to our bodies (i.e. abortion) institutionally debated by a group of outsiders. Because we will never experience these things, it's easy to be ignorant of their effects. The current cultural status quo unquestionably benefits men over women.

A good analogy is bullying. Imagine two high school students: one is popular while the other is picked on constantly. The popular student has nothing but fond memories of the school, never aware that bullying ever occurs, while the bullied student lives under constant unease and fear. Now imagine the two students meet and the bullied student tries to convince the popular student that bulling is in fact, a massive problem. The popular student can either a) try to dismiss the problem or worse, become violent in hopes of defending their fond memories of the school, or b) listen to what the other student has to say, and accept that the reality of their high school experience might not be the same for everyone.

This is why literally the most important thing a male feminist can do is simply listen. Too often men either deny or turn violent in an effort to discredit and silence women for trying to point out the inequality they face. Anita Sarkeesian, creator of the excellent YouTube channel Feminist Frequency, receives heaps of uninvited vitriol and threats whenever she posts a video or makes a public appearance. All she seeks to do is draw attention to the poor representation of women in video games in a very civil and academic way, while also constantly reassuring her audience that it is still possible to enjoy as well as criticize any form of entertainment (insisting that she still enjoys many of the games she talks about). And yet, she inevitably receives negative reactions from people who at best try to discredit her and at worst threaten to rape or murder her. Rather than take into consideration the thoughtful perspective she presents, a disturbing number of individuals would rather scream in protest in hopes of preserving a system they are already comfortable with, regardless of whether it disproportionately benefits them over others. 

If you are a man, the next time a woman presents you with a feminist perspective, I beg you to listen to what they have to say. It's important to listen, and also to understand...


. . . that by doing so, you lose nothing.

It costs nothing to listen but time. It takes little effort to open your ears to what is being said, to take a backseat and accept that someone different from you with different experiences has something to say. Any advice article on relationships undoubtably says the two most important components in a healthy partnership are honesty and communication. The thing about communication is that it has to involve one party talking and one party listening; a discussion quickly becomes an argument when one side talks but refuses to listen. 


You don't have to agree with everything being said, you're not required to evaluate your whole life with new information, and you're not expected to give anything up too. It's important to keep that last point in mind, because...


. . . feminists aren't trying to take anything away from men.

All feminists truly want is for women to be treated as equally as men, to have the same opportunities, to be judged the same way, and to not face discrimination simply because of their gender. Detractors of feminism often take a glass half-empty approach instead of understanding the flip side of their arguments. Feminists don't hate men, they love women; feminists aren't trying to steal your job, they're trying to give women access to the same career opportunities as you; feminists aren't trying to steal your paycheque, they just want to be paid equally for their work; feminists don't want you to stop holding doors for women, they just want you to do it because it's the polite thing to do and not because you find someone sexually attractive; feminists want the same female representation in movies, comics, television, and games as men, not because they want to detract from what's currently available, but because they want something that appeals to them too.

If after that you feel like something is taken away from you, then at best you're just being selfish and at worst you're an incorrigible asshole. If you feel so entitled to jobs you think women aren't qualified for or movies with poor female representation, then you've placed your own opinion and comfort ahead of the security and liberty of another group of people. If that's the case, you probably suffer from... 


. . . toxic masculinity, and here's what that actually means. 

People who genuinely oppose feminism cling to the notion that men and women are inherently different and that each gender must act a certain way. They believe men are big, strong, breadwinners and women are gentle, feminine creatures. This attitude is what is referred to as "toxic masculinity" and insists that each gender must conform to a set of expectations. It tells young boys they have to play sports, that they can't enjoy feminine things or be gay less they be "sissies," and that they need to dominate over women both in physical presence and practical skills.

This notion might seem extreme, but the effect of toxic masculinity permeates in very real ways: it's men who don't dare date stronger or taller women because they can't stand the thought of being the physically weaker partner; it's men insisting that they solely do household chores like woodwork or carpentry, even if their girlfriend is more capable than them; it's boyfriends who end relationships because their girlfriends make more money than them. These are all examples I've encountered personally, and they are all founded on the male insecurity of not living up to a fictional masculine ideal.

The notion of masculinity itself is not inherently harmful, but this rigid expectation of what a man should be is incredibly unhealthy, and it harms men just as much as women. It traps both genders and represses people from pursuing their passions and reaching their true potential. This is why men need to embrace feminism and...


. . . be more mindful, because feminism helps everyone.

The reason feminism exists as a movement is to spread awareness about the inequality women still face - it is an attempt to teach. Being an effective male feminist requires an ability to listen and be mindful of one's own experience as it applies to others. 

It's perfectly natural to find women attractive, whether it's a celebrity, a friend, or a stranger on the street, but it's important to remember that they are a whole person not defined solely by their appearance. It's also fine to watch pornography for sexual gratification, so long as you remember that (like all movies) what you're watching is not an accurate representation of reality. And it's fine to ask a girl on a date, so long as you remember that they're free to reject you in the same way you are free to reject someone you're not entirely interested in. Women don't owe men anything, whether it's obedience, affection, or attention.

The golden rule when it comes to navigating what is and isn't appropriate when interacting with women is to ask, "would I do this if they were a man?" If you wouldn't say/do something to a man, you probably shouldn't say/do it to a woman. In summation...


. . . there are three steps to being a good male feminist.

1) Listen: People who take up causes love to make it their own, to assign their own ideals, to co-opt it for their own sense of self-importance. Your job as a man isn't to protect women, it's to be open to a different person's experience and to offer support - to listen.

2) Be Mindful: Awareness goes a long way, whether it's about your own actions or the actions of others. Recognize when the things you enjoy might not benefit or satisfy others in the same way: you can still enjoy movies and video games that misrepresent women, you can still admire a woman's appearance, and you can still laugh at a dirty joke, but acknowledging the problematic elements of these things stops them from becoming an unhealthy, subconscious part of your reality. 

3) Encourage Others: The most important thing you can do as a male feminist - the thing that will truly go the farthest in furthering the movement and helping women - is to speak up and correct the problematic behaviour of other men when you see it. When your friend makes an inappropriate comment toward a woman, tell them it's not okay. If you're at a party and you witness a man pressuring a woman into something she doesn't want to do, step in. Confrontation is difficult and it is unquestionably easier to do nothing and remain in a comfortable little bubble, but your comfort may come at a cost to someone else, and being a true male feminist may require you to occasionally get your hands dirty. 

That's what I believe it takes to be a proper male feminist. I hope this has maybe helped clear a few things up, and please feel free to share this if you desire. 

And before I go...


. . . here are some extra thoughts.

There are a few final comments I couldn't find a space for naturally in this article, so I'd like to mention them here.


The first is that I believe the most heinous circumstance in which women are devalued in society is in the case of rape accusations. The percentage for falsified rape reports is the same as any other crime at 2%, so it's time to stop pretending it doesn't happen and downplay/dismissing instances when it does. One in four women will be sexually assaulted, which means that many of your female friends may be victims. Rape is a crime like any other, yet it is the only one where a victim's credibility is continually brought into question. I believe men must come to the uncomfortable realization that rape and sexual assault are far more prevalent than we think, and that not all rapists are stalkers hiding in dark alleys. The cold hard fact is that some of your friends may be rapists; you may have committed rape without even realizing it. Admitting rape exists is scary, and admitting you may have contributed to the problem is downright terrifying, but consent is simple: if a woman says no, or is unable to say yes, then the instance in question is rape. To continue to degrade and question victims in order to support our comfortable facade is, quite frankly, disgusting.

Second, I didn't touch much on the idea of objectification, wherein women are presented as objects to be consumed by men. Essays and articles have been written to much greater effect than this blog, but what I want to mention is the unhealthy response men often have as a direct result of this "consumption" of the female body. 

The outcry that often comes up over public breastfeeding and images of menstrual blood (such as Instagram's recent controversy) make it painfully obvious how objectionable men are to being presented with images of women as something other than a consumable, sexual object. Demanding that women cover up in these natural instances - while aggressively consuming fetishized representations of the female form - is outrageous and selfish. 

Finally, many months ago we had a debate in this country over a woman's right to wear the Niqab. The majority viewed the piece of clothing as a representation of women's oppression and campaigned for its ban. This mindset was donned with the best of intentions, under the pre-tense of protecting women. Where this mindset failed was in mindfulness, and in a willingness to understand that truly embracing women's rights might include permitting something we find uncomfortable. We tell women they are free to wear what they want, but when confronted with a woman who genuinely wanted to wear something that made us uncomfortable, we came up with a number of excuses to make it go away.

We insisted we cared more about women, insisted we were better than a culture often associated for restricting what women can and can't do, but our solution was to furthermore try and restrict what women could and couldn't do. We wanted to ban the Niqab because it would make us feel safe, but by trying to cure an ailment we began imitating the disease. If we truly care about women being free, we have to be ready to accept that some women may do things we find uncomfortable. We came dangerously close to being a country that not only culturally shames women for wearing too little clothing, but quite literally make it illegal for them to wear too much.

These extreme situations have been coming up a lot lately. The Niqab debate, Donald Trump's campaign for presidency, Britain's recent vote to exit the European Union - all of these events have torn down a facade and revealed that our civilized cultures are still rooted in sexism, racism, and fear mongering. I hope we can do better, and I pray my recent cynicism will slowly dissipate as time goes on. Certain aspects of human nature will never change; we will always fear what we don't understand, but hopefully with proper education, insight, and mindfulness, we can begin to do better.

Monday, 6 October 2014

This Man Does Not Represent Us . . .

I doubt anyone will remember the title of this article, but it's a line from The Simpsons that always makes me laugh to think about because of the way it's delivered. The episode is entitled "D'oh-in' in the Wind" and follows Homer as he tries to reconnect with the spirit his mother stood for by befriending two of her aging hippy friends (played by Martin Mull and George Carlin). At the end of the episode, Homer messes something up as per usual, and as the police or whomever bear down on the poor older gents, Homer grabs the two hippies in headlocks and says something to the effect that they'll never back down even if they have their skulls beaten in. And then George Carlin, in one of the best deliveries ever, says: "This man does not represent us."

I don't know if there's a sound bite of that already, but there damn well should be.

I was reminded of that line after watching and reflecting on the Internet's latest orgasm - a verbal tussle between Ben Affleck and Bill Maher. For those unaware, Affleck was on Maher's show and provided what amounted to a verbal slap to the TV host by calling him out as racist for his comments regarding Islam. Maher and another of his guests were trying to argue that as liberals they should be campaigning for rights of equality and such, and that according to polls 90% of Islamic people hold beliefs that are counter to those ideals. Maher argued that this was a serious issue and essentially called for some sort of action against it. Affleck, in response (or the best he could do because barely anyone would let that hunk of man-meat speak) pulled a Batman and swooped in to defend those without a voice in the debate and said it was racist of Maher and his other guest to paint all Islamic people with a broad stroke and make claims regarding their beliefs. 

I had just watched Gone Girl the night I saw the video so I was already on a magnificent Affleck high, and God bless 'em. I normally enjoy Maher's rants and opinions, but he always felt a bit too much like a liberal extremist to me (if there is such a thing). I enjoyed his movie Religulous and thought it did a good job of demonstrating just how absurd the institution of religion can be. What I didn't enjoy, however, was that his call to action at the end of the film was for the eradication of all religion because it's essentially an atom bomb waiting to annihilate the planet.

Bit of a stretch there, Maher. Religion was only ever an excuse for war - people will still find reasons to destroy one another without that calling card. Not to mention that he completely ignores the benefits that religion has had for many, many individuals, and the positive nature of spirituality as a whole.

And he pretty much did it again on his show, and thankfully there was a giant, beautiful man with rippling biceps and a chiseled chin of the gods to oppose him. After reflecting on the incident, I came away with two points:

1) Bill Maher is a rich, white, liberal male. As such, he only has authority to make claims on the beliefs of other rich, white, men. He's at his best when he's criticizing congress because he's attacking people in his own demographic, but he in no way has any authority to comment on the beliefs and practices of the world's second largest religion and the people who follow its ideologies when he is so ridiculously far removed from them economically and culturally. I felt a little disgusted listening to the audience applaud his rants because it felt akin to an evangelist declaring a moral war on (insert conservative phobia here) and his followers with no minds of their own clapping in agreement. 

2) Maher is essentially declaring himself the thought police. His main point (let's just ignore how ridiculous it was for the sake of argument) was that 90% of Islamic people hold counter ideologies to the liberal west, and we should therefore develop some sort of strategy to contend with that. My big takeaway from this was that he was declaring war on their beliefs. You can criticize actions (violent or otherwise) all you want, but the moment you start declaring a moral war because of the way people think,  then you've become a villain of Orwellian proportions. Islam is a religion with close to a billion followers. It doesn't matter what they believe - having a late-night talk show doesn't give you moral authority to break into their clubhouse and tell them how they should be running things.

Which brings me around to The Simpsons quote. As a white liberal male myself, I just kept thinking that someone should throw that line out there somewhere in the debate, both because Maher doesn't represent me or my beliefs even though we technically fall into the same political spectrum, and also on behalf of Islamic people everywhere to say "It doesn't matter what polls or studies this white guy has his hands on, he doesn't represent us."

As Batfleck tried to point out, you can't associate the actions of a small percentage of violent extremists with the culture as a whole. He also tried to remind Maher that historically Christians have killed a hell of a lot more of their people than they us, and also we kinda invaded two of their nations with less than probable cause and they sorta have a right to be a bit pissed about that.

Many years ago I was at a family dinner and one of my relatives remarked something that didn't quite sit well with me. One of my cousins is in the military, as was her boyfriend. My relative thanked him for his service but then added "Better we go over there and get them before they come over here and get us." Maher's position strikes me as very similar; we divide the world into us and them, which therefore makes it easier to declare moral war because we are right and they therefore must be wrong. Justifying our own acts of violence because someone somewhere might be harboring ill thoughts against us is like slaughtering deer with the excuse that without thinning out their numbers they'll all just starve. That sort of mentality has caused more damage to the human race than any single religion or set of beliefs; I would go so far as to say that mentality is at the heart of every conflict - big and small - in the history of the human race: you are different and I don't like that.

You're a funny guy Maher, but you should probably limit yourself to just being a late-night entertainer and stop calling for action in your personal war against things that oppose your personal values.

And Affleck . . . please, don't ever change.

Monday, 28 July 2014

Movie Controversy: "Sucker Punch" and Meta-Feminism

There are many movies that spur controversy, and some rightfully deserve it, but if you'll allow me, I'd like to have a little fun playing devil's advocate. 

Zack Snyder's 2011 film Sucker Punch was easily dismissed as a teenage boy's wet dream of flashy special effects and young girls running around doing impossibly awesome things. The film was not popular with, well . . . anyone (despite a cameo by Jon freakin' Hamm). It was attacked by critics, moviegoers, and feminist circles who didn't take too kindly to it because of said young girls being put on display. It came across as an orgy of everything wrong with pop culture. 

While I'm not willing to argue and say such disgust isn't well founded (because it's not my right to tell you what you should and shouldn't be offended by) I've always thought the film was misunderstood. In fact, I would go as far as to say most people who dismissed it as chauvinistic schlock sorta missed the entire point. 

I always thought the film could be the subject of a rather interesting essay, and since no one else has really done so, I've decided to take a deeper look at it myself. I don't want to give the impression that I'm staunchly defending it, however, or that I'm directly calling out people who took issue with it. Much like accusations of racism circling white-boy Tarantino's black-slave driven murder fest Django Unchained, I think it's worth discussing, so imagine me sitting humbly in a rocking chair, stroking my chin as you present your viewpoint, and then in a very civil and polite manner saying: "You raise a very interesting argument, but have you considered this . . ."

For those unfamiliar, Sucker Punch follows a young girl, Babydoll (Emily Browning) who is wrongfully sent to a mental institution thanks to her douchebag step-father over an inheritance dispute. While incarcerated, she befriends a number of other patients including Rocket (Jena Malone), Sweet Pea (Abbie Cornish), Amber (Jamie Chung) and Blondie (Vanessa Hudgens). As part of her step-father's dastardly plan, Babydoll is scheduled to be subjected to a visit from the "High Roller" (played by the aforementioned Jon "Massive Cock" Hamm) who will silence her for good. The poor girl plans an escape with her fellow patients under the nose of the equally awful warden, Blue Jones (Oscar Isaac).

The hook of the film is that the majority of the story takes place in Babydoll's imagination, or at least in her re-imagining of reality. It gets a bit Inception-y in it's fantasy-within-a-fantasy setting. It's hinted that the girls in the asylum are bought out by the warden as sex workers for whomever is willing to pay, and in order to make this reality not so horribly fucking bleak, Babydoll imagines everything around her happening in a nostalgic prohibition-era brothel. She imagines her and her fellow patients as dancers (hence their nicknames) who must perform for Blue Jones' clientele. Blue Jones wants them to dance because it is based on their performances that his clients "purchase" the girls, and Babydoll seems to have a natural affinity for it.

Furthermore, when Babydoll actually "dances," she's transported even further away from reality deeper into her imagination. As part of the girls' escape plan, they must collect a series of items such as a map, lighter, and knife, and Babydoll's dancing is used as a distraction to collect these items. When she dances, the viewer is treated to stylized action sequences where the girls fight killer samurai, dragons, Nazi-zombies, and robots. 

That's quite a bit of context for the film, but it's important to set up just how inextricably detailed the plot is as it's presented to the viewer, at least for the purpose of this article. 

The majority of criticisms hurled against the film are at face-value, claiming it's nothing but glorified violence with scantily-clad female protagonists designed to appeal to misogynistic teenage boys. The teenage boys (or whomever actually liked the film) meanwhile - many of whom have never been in possession of a vagina and thus have no fucking clue what they're talking about - defend it by saying it's "empowering" to women. 

I would argue both parties are wrong.

Zack Snyder has said countless times that he doesn't frame any of the girls in a sexual way, and if you watch the film, he actually doesn't. Their outfits while in murder-porn fantasy mode aren't actually very revealing at all (refer to the movie poster for details) and there aren't any camera shots designed to present them as sexualized objects, except while the film is in brothel-mode, but more on that in a minute. Snyder quite cleverly claims that if you're viewing the girls in a sexualized way, you're doing it because that's what you personally - as a sick, sex-driven misogynist - are doing. He just presented you with some attractive girls performing a bunch of kick-ass stunts. If you get a boner because of it, then it's your own damn fault.

The film quite literally claims very early that there is nothing at all sexy about the girls' predicament. As the story transitions from reality to semi-reality (i.e. the brothel) Sweet Pea is on a stage initially partaking in a form of psychological therapy with Dr. Vera Gorski (Carla Gugino) which transitions into the practice of a new dance routine where she pretends to be a helpless mental patient. Halfway through the performance she stands up, practically mortified, and proclaims that there's absolutely nothing sexy about framing a sex show around someone in such a vulnerable position. 

It couldn't get more obvious if it came out and slapped you in the face.

This is where the biggest chunk of criticisms against the film can be undermined, because everyone focused on the crazy stylized action-violence portions of the film, but no one seemed to pay attention to the context surrounding those bits. The fanboys who tried to defend it by claiming it was "empowering" also missed the fact that in the reality of Babydoll's world, no matter how much she tries to rebel and fight, she ultimately fails. Of the five girls partaking in the escape plan, only one escapes. Three are killed and our protagonist is left lobotomized. It didn't matter how goddamn hard they all fought, the odds were always stacked against them. They fought for a mile and only gained an inch. The girl's struggle against their male oppressors is actually really fucking bleak and depressing.

It almost reads like a metaphor for rebellion against patriarchy.

Babydoll lives in a man's world, under the constant objectification and abuse of men. Her step-father imprisons her, Blue Jones abuses and tries to sell her, she's constantly ogled and demeaned by the audience and workers at the brothel, and the High Roller - although very regretful in the role he must play - ultimately does the most physical damage to her. Babydoll's only male ally is in the form of the Wise Man (Scott Glenn) who appears in her fighting fantasies and briefly at the end of the film during Sweet Pea's escape, which is arguably still a fantasy in Babydoll's mind, so of all the men in the film the only one who actually helps her is a figment of her imagination. Even Dr. Gorski, who is shown to be a woman of some authority in the hospital, is ultimately powerless to help the girls in their struggle against the oppression of Blue Jones and his entourage.

The big "meta" moment for me came when I was lamenting that we as an audience aren't privileged to watching Babydoll "dance," which is presented as some transcendental experience within the context of the film. Everyone she performs for is left hypnotized, and it is the main tool with which the girls distract their captors to steal the items needed for their escape. And then it hit me, and it was so goddamn obvious that it makes me mad that I didn't realize it when I first watched the film.

We as the audience do get to see her dance, we're just presented with it in a different fashion. We play right into Zack Snyder's hand to prove his point that the only sexualization that happens is that which we imprint ourselves. In the film, Babydoll "dances" for Blue Jones and his clientele on a stage. Then the transition happens to the stylized action sequences, and we as the film audience become the clientele, watching her on the stage of the movie screen. We are hypnotized and distracted from the horrible reality these girls are living in, just as much as the men Babydoll is performing for within the film's plot. Snyder turns the table on us, essentially equating the people in the audience with the horrible people watching the girls in the film's world. The girls don't enjoy dancing/fighting; they're doing it as a means to escape from abuse, but those sequences are exactly what we as an audience are paying to see. 

The film may seem like porn to teenage boys who are obsessed with young girls and who overdose regularly on violence and carnage, but it's not condoning that sort of entertainment, it's actively condemning it. Snyder is the real Blue Jones, parading these girls in front of us as an audience and saying, "This is what you sick fucks wanted, right? Well, here you go!" The problem the film faced upon release is that people only saw the first half of that equation and not the second half. They saw the smorgasbord of young women and immediately labelled it as misogynistic without taking into context the rest of the plot or the overall message of the film.

You could easily argue that it was a fault on Snyder's part for not making his point more obvious. After all, it's the responsibility of the filmmaker to make sure whatever message they're trying to convey is communicated properly. And there's so much being said about the nature of reality, fantasy, and escapism in the movie that it can all seem overwhelmingly complicated. As I said before, I'm not necessarily trying to defend the film, but just trying to present all the evidence so that you can make a more informed decision about whether you truly hate it or not.

And that's my two-cents. I thought the film was entertaining enough when I first saw it, but it wasn't until I had a long hard think about it that I started to understand the tapestry Snyder was trying to weave, and which failed to connect with an audience. At this point in cinema history, the film seems to have been dismissed into the abyss, to be forgotten and ignored. I haven't read too many other analysis of it that break it down the way I just tried, but I definitely think it's worth a second viewing if you were quick to label it as shlock on your first go. 

But that's just my opinion. I won't stop you if you want to call me something horrible.